Tuesday, June 9, 2009

The Comparison Trap

{image via here}

Have you ever walked into a friend's home for the first time and immediately felt envious? Have you eyed a completely put-together woman with her immaculate child politely walking next to her, and wondered why you're not as put-together as her? When reading a blog, have you ever thought, "Wow, I wish I could do that?" It's the comparison trap.

I've been thinking a lot about this lately, about how we as women tend to compare ourselves to other women and ultimately judge how we're measuring up by these perceived standards. When we size up the other women to see how we fare, one of two things happen. We either deem ourselves inferior or we conclude that we are superior. Neither one feels very good to the soul.

I remembered reading about just this thing recently and I finally dug it back up. Stephanie at Stephmodo so eloquently wrote about this topic here and posted a follow-up here. Both of her entries are so worth the time. 

I like that she hits upon blogging in her follow up entry. She states that "judging a person by his/her blog is even more inaccurate... remember a blog shares edited information". This is so true. 

It's good to remember that age old saying, "you can't judge a book by it's cover". There's always more to the story. At the same time as we are allowing ourselves to pale in comparison to someone else, another person could be elevating you in their eyes. Let's even the playing field and see our own worth. It's huge.

27 comments:

erikamommy said...

WOW Erin! This really hits home for me b/c I am constantly feeling inferior. Whether it is my parenting, how I look or what kind of wife I am. I try not to compare b/c there it is such a time waster but I really have to consciously make an effort not to do it. Thank you for your uplifting words!

Jenny said...

E, that was a really good post. It really makes you think. I am about to go read those posts you linked to also.
Thanks for such great words today!

nkp said...

Wow! That post was huge. Well said, Lady!

Julia said...

Exactly what I needed to hear this morning! Thank you so, so much!

Miss Aimee said...

great words. XO

Rachel said...

So completely true! Thanks for the reminder! I feel empowered now...

Blair said...

Oh, my! What a nice thought to start the day! I know exactly what you are talking about. I constantly compare myself, my home, my blog, my life to all my friends and peers and constantly feel this way and you are so right that it does not feel very good to the soul. I haven't read the post you linked to yet but I very much look forward to it!

Helen said...

Too true! Well put, Erin. Why do we, as women, do this? It's so painful, really.

Lizzy said...

What an inspiring post! It's so true, I tend to even compare myself to the skinny model looking gal standing in front of me in line at Pete's.

Rita Finn said...

More and more, I've gotten away from that, though any hint of envy is a happy, and well-wishing envy that compells me to improve. I have more difficulty keeping up with myself than with others!

Kristin said...

Well said. Envy does seem to drive me sometimes rather than accomplishing things for my own worth. Job envy, house envy, mommy envy, they all haunt me a bit. But then other times I look at my little dude's face and realize I've got things pretty good. : )

Katie said...

Oh, I am SO guilty of this. Not so much in the blog world, more IRL. I've been working on it lately, and I think the real problem, at least for me, is lacking a clearly defined "self." I'll see my friend dressed perfectly and put together in an outfit and then I want to go and buy the same one, even though it's not my taste at all. What I really want is to look the way she does- put together, confidant, and self-assured. It's not the outfit, but the woman behind it.

I struggle with it all the time; trying to make sure something is really me rather than a copycat of something I really don't even want.

Great post!

our little love nest said...

So true! I have so gone there and it isn't a pretty place...eek. It is so much better to see that God made us each unique and beautiful with special interwoven purposes that blend together like puzzle pieces in this life if we allow them to be that way. I keep being inspired by you and you definitely have a beauty and purpose that has so struck a chord with my life. I love it! xo

Mary said...

Excellent post. I recently posted about this, too. It's good to continue to remind ourselves to focus on all the ways we're doing great and not to compare ourselves to others. Thanks!

http://mwazloves.blogspot.com/2009/04/perception-is-reality.html

jess@noelmarie said...

Really great post! I know I look at other people (and certainly other blogs) and think that I wish I had what they had. I'm trying to stop this since, you're right and we shouldn't compare ourselves to others.

But it is fun to really be happy for other people. I have found lately that when I allow myself to fully be happy for others it feels just as good as if it was for myself (ok, not just as good, but close).

dmoms said...

been there done that. I wrote about it once too. everyone else seems so much better syndrome. i'm over it now. but, I know what you mean!!

Miss Aimee said...

erin, been thinking about your post all day as it has bothered me some because you are such an amazing person the little I know of you-who has so much going for you and your family that you should never have these thoughts EVER. I dont ever feel like this- maybe that makes me strange- I have, in college some... but am way over it and take on a new attitude that is more competitive with myself then anything. I know these people though who feel this and it makes me sad bc we are all so perfect in our own way OUR OWN individual ways that each and every one in the world has something new and fresh to give and you have soooo many I am just amazed that you ever feel like this. Anyway- just my wrapped up thoughts on this today. YOU are AMAZING. be you, love you, and love it all, even the imperfections, right(bc like you said we all have them, and THAT is normal)!! maybe I read into your post to deep...just was thinking about it today. See you thursday

Sixpence and a Blue Moon said...

I'm guilty! What a beautiful post - and you said it all so well. Had I tried to put this post together, it would be like a chopped salad with ingredients that do not go together. I needed to read this today, thank you!

Joyce said...

Erin, Did my husband emailed you today?! I was having a similiar conversation with him today about me and my feelings of not measuring up, about the nasty looking tummy scars from the nasty surgery about the nasty weight gain from the nasty surgery... This post really touched me. THANK YOU!!

Amy said...

I compare all the time - I look at all the blogs out there and think no one wants to read my crap and that I can't do anything original - I need to stop worrying about it - if it makes me happy then I should shut up and do it! Great post!

lily pottery said...

thank u for sharing this. i stumbled across your blog and found this post and...WOW...it's so good. thank u!

Rebecca said...

so very true! thank you for sharing...it can be tough not to get caught in the cycle of comparing...it's such a daily practice.

Haven and Home said...

This is a really good post, came just when I needed it!

down and out chic said...

sometimes i focus on not judging others so much i end up leaving all the judgment to myself. i really need to be careful with that!
great post.

Heather said...

So true, and it definitely happens more on the days when I feel unshowered, flustered, and generally behind the eight ball!

LipstickOne said...

soooo true!

Katie said...

Thanks for sharing this! i find myself falling into this trap all the time!